Major garden centres shut down use of neonic pesticides
Neonic-free garden plants. -AWARE Simcoe photo
From Friends of the Earth Canada
A Friends of the Earth Canada survey has revealed a major victory for bees and pollinators. Canada’s big box stores are reporting they have almost eliminated the sale of neonicotinoid-contaminated flowering plants.
Friends of the Earth Canada has spent the last five years testing flowering plants from garden centres across Canada for bee-toxic neonicotinoid pesticides. Neonics are systemic pesticides that are taken up by the whole plant and contaminate the nectar and pollen which is so important to native bees, honey bees and other pollinators.
Friends of the Earth Canada surveyed 12 major garden centre chains this spring to gauge the progress in eliminating neonicotinoid-contaminated flowering plants.
“In the context of our long term flower testing and the results of this year’s survey, we have real cause to celebrate Pollinator Week (June 17-24) this year,” said Beatrice Olivastri, CEO, Friends of the Earth Canada.
Top place for neonic-free flowering plants goes to two big box chain stores and one regional chain: Home Depot, Lowes (which includes RONA and Reno-Depot Corporate stores across Canada and Sheridan Nurseries in Ontario. As a close second, Canadian Tire Corporation reported that it has reached 95% neonicotinoid free.
View our detailed chart – 2019 Policy on Use of Bee-toxic Neonics by Largest Garden Centres across Canada – to learn more about how major garden centres are shutting down their use of neonic pesticides.
“Saving the bees is important to Canadians. We’re very pleased to congratulate Home Depot and Lowes (including RONA), Sheridan Nurseries and Canadian Tire for their leadership in responding to consumers’ deep concerns about neonic-contamination of flowering plants,” says Ms Olivastri.
Home Hardware reports 100% neonic-free products from its distribution centres, but Friends of the Earth notes that many Home Hardware stores host local nurseries and it is not clear that their plants are neonic-free.
Both Costco and Walmart report progress in removing neonics on their websites, but are not reporting on Canadian-specific markets.
Loblaw, with the largest number of outlets – some 2500 in Canada – is recycling its 2016 statement saying that since 2014 it has been “developing a plan”.
Empire Company, which owns Sobey, IGA, Safeway and other stores, has not responded to Friends of the Earth.
In Ontario, Sheridan Nurseries continues to report plants and seeds as neonic-free, but there is no response from Atlantic Canada’s Kent Chain, Quebec’s Botanix Garden Centres or BC’s Art Knapp Plantland. Friends of the Earth hopes they will respond soon.
“We asked gardeners to insist on neonic-free plants to protect bees – in response to consumer demand, garden centres have moved in advance of government regulations to shut down neonic use,” says Ms. Olivastri. We hope gardeners will keep demanding neonic-free flowers when they shop for plants.
The federal government has announced a phase-out of these pesticides for use with most ornamental plants including herbs such as lavender and rosemary but in two years’ time.
It has refused to take action on field crops and grain, which means millions of hectares of agricultural land are contaminated every year.